INSIGHTS

On 12 November 2026, Deputy High Court Judge Yuen handed down judgment in Yao Hua Kang v Joe Hsiang Lin [2026] HKCFI 6115, allowing the defendant’s appeal against an order made by a Master for a split trial, and dismissing the plaintiff’s summons, with costs. The decision can be viewed here.

This decision underscores the primacy of the Court of Appeal’s judgment in Telford Development Ltd v Shui On Construction Co Ltd [1990] 2 HKC 110, in which it was held that:

The general rule is that all the issues in a case are to be tried at one and the same time. There is power to order that different issues in a case be tried at different times. But that departure from the general rule is ordered only if it is just and convenient. And it is, of course, for the party who seeks such a departure to demonstrate that it is indeed just and convenient.

The decision also highlights the perils of a poorly drafted attempt to overly simplify the issues ahead of trial.

The learned Judge considered that the first issue formulated by the plaintiff’s advisers did not “adequately recognize the many issues between the parties as to what were their contractual rights and obligations to start with, and what became of them as events transpired”; and that “a judge tasked with trying such a narrowly formulated issue would find himself intolerably hamstrung”.

As to the second issue put forward on behalf of the plaintiff (an issue on liability), the learned Judge held that the basis of liability was not specified.

The learned Judge also held that the plaintiff had not shown there would be any saving in time and costs if the order were to be made, concluding that “in light of the disputed facts and the parties’ apparently changing positions over time, a comprehensive, once-and-for-all finding of facts would be beneficial to the legal analysis of the parties’ rights and obligations that the judge must perform at the conclusion of the trial”.

Sebastian Hughes, instructed by Lewis Man and his team at Munros, appeared on behalf of the defendant.